- The Wall Street Journal (June 19,
2012)
By RAKESH SHARMA
NEW DELHI—India and China's largest oil companies
have agreed to jointly explore for oil and gas world-wide, in an attempt to put
aside long-standing rivalry and better use their combined financial muscle and
expertise to secure energy supplies for their fast-growing economies.
While the two energy-deficient countries
already work together on several international oil projects, they also have a
long history of bad relations, and of proposing cost-reducing alliances to
jointly buy foreign energy assets and crude-oil that mostly have come to nothing.
According to an initial pact signed Monday
between state-run Oil & Natural Gas Corp. of India and
China National Petroleum Corp., the two will jointly explore assets in other
countries, cementing existing partnerships in Myanmar, Syria and Sudan.
"We think it is better to cooperate than
compete," said Dinesh Sarraf, managing director of ONGC Videsh Ltd.,
ONGC's overseas investment arm.
ONGC Chairman Sudhir Vasudeva last month said
the explorer wants to grow through partnerships and will secure alliances for
new resource types and areas like shale gas and deepwater exploration.
China has been more successful than India in
getting oil and gas equity stakes across the globe, often providing large loans
and funding for infrastructure projects in developing nations to tie up deals
signed by its four state-owned energy giants, the largest of which is CNPC and
its listed unit, PetroChina Co.
Tensions between India and China have been
troubled by a long-simmering border dispute in the Himalayas, India's hosting
of Tibetan spiritual leader the Dalai Lama, and Chinese support for Pakistan.
Relations took a turn for the worst last year because of a sovereignty row in
the South China Sea, much of which is claimed by Beijing.
ONGC, which had been exploring Block 128
offshore Vietnam, was sharply criticized by China last year for violating its
sovereignty—a charge Hanoi vehemently rejected. Last month, India's junior oil
minister, R.P.N. Singh, said the company will return the block to Vietnam.
Whether that decision was significant in the
agreement on a new pact is unclear.
In January 2006, India's oil ministry and
China's economic planning agency, the National Reform and Development
Commission, signed an initial pact for bilateral oil cooperation, including
possible joint crude purchases.
But five years later, Mr. Singh conceded that
progress had been slow as "there has been no sharing of information on
crude purchases by the oil companies of the two sides."
India hasn't been very open to Chinese
companies investing in either its energy or telecommunications sectors, citing
security concerns, although Chinese power-generation equipment companies have
been successful in the Indian market.
Among projects that ONGC Videsh is working on
with CNPC is a pipeline to transport Myanmar gas from the Bay of Bengal across
the country into southwestern China, which is due for completion next year.
The two also work together in Syria, where
they jointly hold stakes in 36 producing fields, as well as in Sudan, although
oil output there has largely halted due to military clashes between North and
South Sudan.
Both CNPC and ONGC are among companies that
have expressed interest in building an oil pipeline from South Sudan to Kenya's
East African coast, to bypass the traditional export route through the north.
Hong Kong-based Mirae Asset analyst Nipun
Sharma said the latest agreement seems to be merely a renewal of an existing
exploration pact.
"The previous pact only resulted in a
handful of projects, including one in Sudan. This time around, if the two
nations are able to better align their economic and political interests, we could
see more joint exploration projects ahead.
"This would be a definite positive for
ONGC, which needs to accelerate its internationalization program in order to
increase production and reduce its exposure to domestic oil pricing
risks."
Indian exploration companies have been
seeking partnerships with other overseas oil and gas majors to gain access to
technology that will help them increase output and widen their geographical
footprint.
ONGC signed an initial agreement with ConocoPhillips in March to look for
opportunities for jointly exploring and developing shale-gas reserves in India
and North America and deepwater blocks along India's east coast.
--Simon Hall in Beijing contributed to this
article.
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702303836404577476090216555460.html?mod=WSJASIA_hpp_LEFTTopWhatNews